The best cupcake in NYC is….
Since venturing into the business world of cupcakes, I recently took a trip to NYC in search of the city’s best cupcake!
I went to the three of the most popular bake shops.
First I stopped by Buttercup Bake Shop…
(Might I add this bakery was voted best bakery for 2008)

Vanilla frosted cupcake from Buttercup Bakery

Buttercup Bakery cupcakes
The Verdict: The cake was dry (who wants a dry cupcake? lol) and the frosting was thick and disgusting! Oh sure they look colorful and delicious but unless you like snacking on a stick of butter you won’t like this cupcake! Between my brother, his wife and myself we tried three different kinds….and none of us liked them!
Then I stopped by the Cupcakestop.com truck….
(This truck has only been around for about a year, but they’re all the rage in NYC)

Cupcakestop's cupcake truck
The Verdict: Ok so I’ll be honest the reason I went to see the truck was because the concept was cool. But let’s face it you can’t eat the concept! I’ll give the truck props for creative flavors of cupcakes (like oreo crumb and banana chocolate chip)…but I’d rather eat cardboard. Again the frosting’s were not good and these cupcakes tasted more like a muffin then a cupcake…more like a week old muffin! lol Wouldn’t go there again let’s just put it that way.
Finally I ended up over at Magnolia’s Bakery…

The red velvet cupcake and the chocolate cupcake from Magnolia Bakery.
The Verdict: Ah Magnolia…I have loved thee ever since your days spent on the classic television series “Sex and the City.” Magnolia bakery can frost a cupcake like no one else. Oh sure they’re cupcakes are pretty and cute but it’s hard to believe that Charlotte, Miranda, Carrie and Samantha actually ate them! lol I say this because on the show (if you’ve seen it) they eat the vanilla frosted, vanilla cupcakes. (Quick side note the woman who used to work at Magnolia’s is the same woman who opened up the Buttercup Bake Shop…so you can imagine where I’m going with this) Unless you eat cupcakes every day there’s no way you can tell the difference between Magnolia and Buttercups vanilla frosted cupcakes, they’re twins…and I don’t recommend the vanilla. It’s like an accquired taste for butter lol However their red velvet cupcakes have a light and fluffy frosting which is fantastic, and the cake is moist and delicious! If you don’t like red velvet cake then I suggest chocolate cake with the chocolate frosting….the cake is not as dry as the vanilla and the frosting tastes like chocolate instead of vanilla flavored butter! ![]()
And the winner is (drumroll please!)…..
The red velvet cupcake from Magnolia! If you don’t like red velvet cupcakes you will after you eat one from Magnolia Bakery.
Next time you’re in NYC and you want a cupcake just remember one name…Magnolia!


